Metal vs. Asphalt Roofing: Weighing Longevity, Costs, and Insurance Factors

Blog Img

Metal vs. Asphalt Shingles Roofing Materials

Metal vs. Asphalt Shingles: Choosing the Right Roofing Material for Your Home

When considering the right roofing material for your home, the battle often comes down to metal roofing versus asphalt shingles. The choice you make can be influenced by a variety of factors, particularly where you live.

For those in places like Florida, a higher wind speed rating may be essential due to extreme weather conditions. A metal roof can certainly offer that superior resistance to the elements. However, it's important to consider the long-term implications of your investment, especially in regards to insurance. In some areas, insurance coverage for your roof might become void after 15 to 20 years, no matter whether it's metal or shingle. Therefore, the longevity and durability of your roofing material could be less crucial if you'll be losing insurance coverage in two decades.

Beyond the local climate and insurance considerations, there are several types of metal roofing to choose from: 5V with its characteristic triangles, interlocking standing seam, ribbed panels, and the standard rolls commonly used for sheds. Each comes with its own set of features and installation methods.

Installation and Maintenance Considerations

How a metal roof is affixed is also a crucial detail to ponder. Mechanically fastened roofs using screws or nails may not withstand high winds as well as other methods. Moreover, exposed rubber washers or grommets on the fasteners can deteriorate quickly under the sun, necessitating more maintenance than you might expect with a shingle roof.

Another aspect to examine is the specialist techniques required for certain metal roofs. For example, installing a double-lock standing seam metal roof, which can withstand very high winds, usually needs specialized equipment and experienced professionals – factors which can significantly increase the overall cost.

Costs and Aesthetics

Speaking of costs, metal roofing materials can be 1.5 to 2 times more expensive than shingles, and the labor can be 2 to 3 times higher. These prices can vary depending on the source of the materials and the expertise of the installation crew.

Metal certainly has its aesthetic appeal and versatility. You can find metal roofing that mimics the look of cedar shakes, slate, or tiles. However, when you weigh the potential for lack of extended insurance coverage, maintenance issues, and the complexity of installation, it might not be the best choice for every homeowner. Incorrect installation can lead to tricky and costly repairs due to the lengthy and continuous nature of metal panels – a stark contrast to the relative ease of replacing a few shingles.

The Verdict on Metal Roofing

If you reside in an area where a metal roof's longevity (30, 40, or even 50 years) can be fully utilized without insurance limitations, a metal option could be highly beneficial. But if you're in a region where your metal roof won't be insured past 20 years, you may want to consider asphalt shingles. Today's shingle technology has improved significantly, offering expected lifespans that extend beyond 20 years even in tough climates like Florida's.

In summary, the decision between metal and shingle roofing boils down to your specific situation – weighing factors like aesthetics, cost, maintenance, installation requirements, and insurance. Make sure to do your research and carefully consider these aspects to make the best decision for your home and your wallet.

recent Posts

All posts